Politics

Italy’s political divides: Prof. Orsina explains the ongoing dynamics in Rome

Italy’s governing coalition is showing divisions over the budget and school textbooks, but the deeper fault line concerns the relationship between sovereignist politics and liberal political culture. According to political scientist Giovanni Orsina, the centre-right is likely to find a compromise, while the centre-left Parliamentary minority remains without a shared programme or an agreed leader

Political coalitions face their greatest tests when money runs short and elections approach. It is precisely in this space, between a tightly constrained budget and an approaching electoral campaign, that Italian politics is revealing its contradictions.

A vote on digital school textbooks has exposed differences between Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s Brothers of Italy and its coalition partner Forza Italia, while the centre-left continues to struggle with divisions affecting even its political identity, as demonstrated by the dispute over the antisemitism bill. Both political camps are confronting their internal differences, but they have not developed the same capacity to manage them.

Why he matters: Giovanni Orsina is Professor of Contemporary History at Luiss University in Rome, where he heads the Department of Political Science. A historian and political scientist, he is among Italy’s leading scholars of conservatism and the Italian right.

  • In this interview with Decode39, Orsina argues that the centre-right has learned to coexist with its internal divisions, while the broad centre-left alliance has yet to find a common political framework. “On the right, there is a political bloc. On the left, there isn’t one.” The problem, he warns, is not simply identifying a leader, but determining which political project could bring together such different perspectives.

Q: Professor, let us start with the centre-right. The vote on digital textbooks showed a governing majority openly divided, with Forza Italia voting against a proposal from Brothers of Italy. Is this a sign of a political crisis, or are we dealing with normal tensions within a coalition?

A: What is happening was largely predictable. The centre-right is a coalition known for being relatively cohesive, but it contains internal fault lines and different political perspectives, which also represent different electorates. For four years, the governing parties have managed, almost miraculously, to maintain consistency and cohesion in government despite their differences.

  • Now we are approaching elections, which will essentially be a proportional contest, and each party needs to plant its own flag. Each needs to present itself to voters by claiming credit for its achievements and asserting its own identity. Tensions, therefore, inevitably increase.

Q: The budget has become the terrain on which these differences are emerging. How much does the scarcity of available resources matter?

A: It matters enormously. The budget is essentially locked down, and the portion of resources that the parties can actually divide among themselves is rather limited. There is very little room for manoeuvre.

  • The European procedures are not yet definitively behind us, the international environment is extremely unstable, and the prospects for additional resources have diminished. Money is scarce, and the parties are arguing over what remains.
  • There is, however, an issue that goes beyond the immediate circumstances of the budget, and which, in my view, is much more important.

Q: Which one?

A: The structural divide between Brothers of Italy and Forza Italia. We see it in their positions on banks, we saw it over school textbooks, and we find it again in various economic policy choices.

  • It is a confrontation between a social-oriented political culture, which characterises Brothers of Italy, and a liberal culture, which belongs to Forza Italia’s tradition.
  • The question is what kind of relationship the Italian right wants to have with the market. This is an enormous issue, which also concerns Europe and the way Western democracies must rethink the free market in the face of Chinese competition.
  • On this point, the Italian right has not yet fully clarified its ideas. The two political cultures coexist, but they are not the same thing. And sooner or later, it will be necessary to understand which of the two will prevail, or how they will manage to find a synthesis.

Q: Could this difference become a problem ahead of the elections? Or has the centre-right now developed the ability to absorb its own contradictions?

A: I believe they will find a compromise. The tensions are visible, but we are in a situation in which the centre-right can quite comfortably aim to win the elections again. That changes things considerably.

  • For now, the parties will use the period between now and the conclusion of the budget session to highlight their respective differences. But from January 1, the electoral campaign will essentially begin. At that point, the need to present voters with a recognisable coalition will once again prevail.
  • The right has already gone through a period of adjustment to the political divisions introduced by populism, between the traditional right and the populist right, and it has somehow managed to handle them.
  • The question of its relationship with the market remains unresolved, but politically, its ability to hold these different components together is more advanced than that of the left.

Q: Let us turn to the broad centre-left coalition. Elly Schlein has argued that the vote on digital textbooks demonstrates that the governing majority no longer exists. But looking at the other side of the political spectrum, the centre-left seems to face even deeper problems.

A: Compared with 2022, progress has been made, and that must be acknowledged. But voters could legitimately have expected that, by this point, at least some common ground on a political programme would already have been found.

  • Instead, the parties continue to fight over practically everything: from a wealth tax to the citizens’ income scheme, and even the war in Ukraine.
  • I would point out that, if we look at the difficulties facing the governing majority, the problems within the broad centre-left alliance are considerably more numerous.
  • The truth is that there is a political bloc on the right. On the left, however, there still is not one. There are not even agreed rules for selecting a leader.
  • And we are potentially six months away from the vote: we have no candidate to lead the coalition and no shared programme.

Q: So is the main problem the coexistence of different political cultures? I am also thinking of international experiences, starting with the United States, where the different components of the Parliamentary minority to Trump managed to come together during the midterm elections.

A: That is precisely the issue. In America, it was possible to build an electoral convergence around opposition to Trump, bringing together different political perspectives. But even there, it remains to be seen who will lead the project ahead of the presidential elections.

  • In Italy, however, the difficulty is even more evident because the divide between the different components of the left has not been resolved even at the European level.
  • The centre-left still needs to find a balance between a more reformist component and a more radical one.
  • And simply bringing parties together is not enough to build a coalition. It is necessary to understand what vision of the country holds them together, which economic policies they want to pursue, and what international positioning they intend to adopt.
  • Otherwise, the risk is that the broad centre-left alliance becomes a collection of opposition forces without turning into a credible alternative government.

Q: Another significant divide emerged during the vote on the antisemitism bill. The legislation has become law, but the broad centre-left alliance was divided, with the Democratic Party split between its leadership and its reformist wing. What does this episode tell us about the identity of the Italian left?

A: It reveals an extremely deep divide, because we have seen how central the question of Israel has become in the redefinition of political identities.

  • There is a left that is naturally and legitimately opposed to the Israeli government, but which recognises Israel’s right to exist, to live and to defend itself.
  • It may judge what the Netanyahu government has done very harshly. It may believe that Israel has changed profoundly compared with the past. But it continues to regard Israel as the country that provided refuge to a persecuted people. This is a political culture that we find in figures such as Piero Fassino, Emanuele Fiano and Lorenzo Guerini.
  • On the other side, there is a more radical left, which is constructing part of its political identity by absorbing the most radical rhetoric of the pro-Palestinian movement.
  • It does not necessarily have to go so far as to use the expression “from the river to the sea,” but it operates within a cultural environment in which recognition of Israel’s right to exist becomes ambiguous, when it is not openly called into question. And this creates an enormous problem for the Democratic Party.

Q: So was the vote on the antisemitism bill primarily a question of political identity, rather than a disagreement over the substance of the legislation?

A: I would say that the substance of the legislation certainly played a role, but the underlying political question is much deeper. The Democratic Party finds itself having to hold together two different political perspectives that have divergent positions on Israel, the Middle East conflict and the relationship with the radical political world. The episode surrounding the antisemitism bill made this ambiguity evident.

  • This is not a problem concerning just one parliamentary vote. It concerns the very identity of the party and its ability to define a recognisable political line. And it is a problem that adds to those already existing over economic policy, Ukraine and leadership.
  • The centre-right, despite all its contradictions, has found a way to manage its differences. The left, on the other hand, still has to demonstrate that it can do the same.

Subscribe to our newsletter